Well, Ellie's intuition was right about her not liking her preschool so we searched for an alternative and found this great Science and Art program that is held in a church right across the street from us! Ellie LOVES these new classes and now is very excited to be going! They are 2 1/2 hours every Monday and Wednesday which has opened up our schedule to relax a little more during the week. Our days are now like this: Monday-Science class, Tuesday-ballet, Wednesday-Art class, Thursday-gymnastics, Friday-free day.
Ellie's new class:

Ellie needed a backpack for this school (her old one provided buckets to use for papers) but she didn't like the ones we looked at at the store. So we just bought a plain blue one on clearance and I told her we would decorate it ourselves. When I asked her what she wanted, she drew a picture for me of an elephant and said "this!".

I looked on-line for an elephant patch and learned, instead, how to make one ourselves. I let Ellie pick out the fabric and she told me exactly how she wanted it to look. Here is the finished product:

We are both very happy with it!